Hearthline Contract comparison

Best home warranty companies of 2026

Pick the contract, not the slogan.

Hearthline lined up five national home-warranty companies by the terms they actually publish: plan menu, dollar caps, workmanship window, and what the cheap tier leaves out. This is not a survey, a star rating, or a paid ranking.

Reviewed November 20, 2026 Five companies Official pages only No tracking links

Start with the job, then the company

A useful “best” is the plan that covers the thing most likely to fail in your house, inside a cap that can actually pay for it.

Highest published cap

American Home Shield

$50,000 aggregate per term on ShieldSilver, ShieldGold, and ShieldPlatinum. Appliance caps rise with the tier.

AHS terms
Longest workmanship claim

Liberty Home Guard

Systems, appliances, or both, plus a long add-on list. Liberty says completed work is guaranteed for 365 days.

Liberty terms
Sticker price on the page

2-10

Systems listed at $39.99 a month and Pinnacle at $59.99. HVAC cap published at $5,000 per system.

2-10 terms
Repair vs replace

Cinch

Repair Only does not replace the item. Repair + Replace does. Every plan cites a 180-day workmanship guarantee.

Cinch terms
Watch the basic plan

Choice

Choice’s own page puts air conditioning, the refrigerator, and the washer and dryer on the Total plan, not the basic list.

Choice terms

Side by side

Dollar figures are the companies’ published numbers, not a quote for your address. “Not published here” means that page did not state a number we were willing to repeat.

Published plan shape for five home warranty companies, November 20, 2026
Company Plans named on their site Published money terms Workmanship Read this before you buy
American Home Shield ShieldSilver, ShieldGold, ShieldPlatinum $50,000 aggregate per agreement term. HVAC up to $5,000. Appliances up to $2,000 on Gold and $4,000 on Platinum. Water heater $1,000 on Silver and Gold, $2,000 on Platinum. 30 days, on completed repairs Service fee is chosen at purchase and was not a single number on the plans page. Coverage is for parts of listed items.
Liberty Home Guard Appliance Guard, Systems Guard, Total Home Guard, plus HVAC Guard Marketed from $1 a day. HVAC Guard listed at $29.99 a month for heating and cooling. Per-item caps were not on the overview page. 365 days, as stated by Liberty Waiting period of 30–60 days unless the plan was bought in a home sale. Add-ons are how the menu gets wide.
2-10 Home Buyers Warranty Systems and Pinnacle Systems $39.99/month. Pinnacle $59.99/month. HVAC up to $5,000. Water heater up to $1,000. Appliances up to $2,000 on Pinnacle. Not stated on the pricing page we used List prices can drop with cart discounts. Roof, pool, guest unit, septic, well, electronics, and refrigerant are add-ons.
Cinch Home Services Repair Only, Repair + Replace, Repair + Replace Premier Repair Only: up to $1,000 per covered appliance, $10,000 per term, deductible $100–$150. Monthly price is quoted by ZIP. 180 days Repair Only excludes replacement. Premier is the tier that includes exterior water, sewer, and gas lines.
Choice Home Warranty Basic coverage list and a Total plan No monthly price on the public explainer. Claims can be settled in cash at Choice’s cost, which can be below retail. Response times are in the policy, not a day count on the explainer Air conditioning, refrigerator, washer, and dryer are described as Total-plan items. In California the contract is issued by Home Service Club of California.

Links on this page go to each company’s public website with no affiliate code attached. Hearthline is not paid for these placements. If that changes, the disclosure at the top will say so.

What the brochure skips

Every one of these companies tells you to read the sample agreement. That document, for your state, beats this page.

  • Service fee or deductible. You pay it on each visit, including visits that end in a denial.
  • Per-item cap and aggregate cap. A $50,000 ceiling does not mean a refrigerator is covered for $50,000.
  • Waiting period. Many contracts will not take a claim in the first month or two, unless coverage starts at a home closing.
  • Pre-existing conditions. “Unknown” and “known” are different words. A noisy system you already live with may be excluded.
  • Cash instead of repair. Some contracts pay the company’s cost, not the price of a new appliance at a store.
  • Code, permits, haul-away, and refrigerant. Often extra, sometimes an add-on, sometimes included on the top tier only.
  • Improper installation and lack of maintenance. A common denial, though American Home Shield says it does not require maintenance records and covers some improper installation.

The five companies

Summaries use language from each company’s public pages. Marketing claims stay attributed to the company.

American Home Shield

Frontdoor brand

ShieldSilver is the systems plan: parts of heating, air conditioning, plumbing, and electrical, described as 20 items. ShieldGold adds kitchen and laundry appliances, described as 27 items. ShieldPlatinum adds roof-leak repair up to $1,000 and exterior water, sewer, and gas lines up to $2,000 per line. AHS says covered items of any age can be included, maintenance records are not required, and unknown pre-existing breakdowns can be covered. Members on select plans can use a video call with a technician from 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. Central, at no extra cost. The workmanship guarantee is 30 days.

Why it makes this list

  • Largest aggregate cap in this set, published at $50,000.
  • Appliance cap is written down: $2,000 on Gold, $4,000 on Platinum.
  • Explicit “no maintenance records” language.

Where it is thinner

  • 30-day workmanship is the shortest window in this set.
  • You still pick a service fee, and non-covered changes can be billed.
  • Roof-leak money is a $1,000 cap, not a new roof.

American Home Shield plans

Liberty Home Guard

Add-on heavy

Liberty sells Appliance Guard, Systems Guard, and Total Home Guard, and it calls the combined plan the most economical of the three. A separate HVAC Guard plan is listed at $29.99 a month and, unlike the main plans, Liberty says it covers pre-existing HVAC conditions with no waiting period once the plan is active. The company says it does not require a home inspection or maintenance records, covers items regardless of age, and offers more add-ons than other providers, including electronics and septic. It also says U.S. News & World Report named it best overall for 2026. That is Liberty’s citation of a third-party list, not a test Hearthline ran. Service requests generally wait 30 to 60 days unless the plan was part of a home purchase.

Why it makes this list

  • Published 365-day workmanship guarantee.
  • You can buy systems only, appliances only, or both.
  • HVAC Guard is a narrow plan with pre-existing coverage called out.

Where it is thinner

  • Overview pages lead with “$1 a day,” not a full rate card.
  • Per-item dollar caps were not on the page we reviewed.
  • The wide menu depends on add-ons you have to price separately.

Liberty Home Guard

2-10 Home Buyers Warranty

Prices on the page

2-10 publishes two homeowner plans with monthly prices: Systems at $39.99 and Pinnacle at $59.99, before cart discounts. Systems covers heating and air conditioning, electrical, and plumbing, with up to $5,000 per heating or AC system and $1,000 per water heater. Pinnacle adds kitchen and laundry appliances at up to $2,000 each. Roof-leak repair, pool and spa, a guest unit up to 750 square feet, septic, well pump, electronics, and HVAC refrigerant are listed as extras rather than part of the base price.

Why it makes this list

  • The monthly price is printed, so a ZIP quote has a public benchmark.
  • Systems-only is a real product if you do not want to insure a refrigerator.
  • Caps for HVAC, water heater, and appliances are written next to the plan.

Where it is thinner

  • The pricing page did not state a workmanship length.
  • Several failures people care about (roof, refrigerant, well) cost more.
  • Built-in bar refrigerators, wine chillers, and kegerators are called out as outside normal appliance coverage.

2-10 plans and pricing

Cinch Home Services

Since 1978

Cinch’s comparison is the clearest about replacement. Repair Only covers repairs to a list of systems and appliances and does not replace the item. Repair + Replace adds replacement. Premier also includes exterior gas, sewer, and water lines, homeowners-insurance deductible reimbursement up to $500 a year, and up to $2,000 a year toward non-covered charges such as permits and disposal. Repair Only lists a $1,000 appliance cap, two units per appliance, a $10,000 term limit, and a $100–$150 deductible. Cinch says unknown pre-existing conditions are covered and that known pre-existing conditions are excluded. Covered repairs carry a 180-day workmanship guarantee.

Why it makes this list

  • The repair-only versus replacement choice is labeled in the plan name.
  • 180-day workmanship is six times AHS’s published window.
  • Premier bundles the exterior-line and permit costs other brands sell separately.

Where it is thinner

  • $10,000 a year is a fifth of AHS’s published aggregate.
  • Repair Only can leave you buying the new appliance yourself.
  • Monthly price is not printed; it depends on the region.

Cinch plans and coverage

Choice Home Warranty

Basic vs total

Choice describes a home warranty as a service contract and says the basic list includes heating and ducts, plumbing, electrical, the water heater, oven, range, cooktop, dishwasher, built-in microwave, disposal, and a few smaller items. The Total plan is where Choice puts air conditioning, the refrigerator, and the clothes washer and dryer. Optional items include pool and spa, well pump, roof leaks, sump pump, and septic. The company says it has a 24/7 call center and a contractor network, and that it may pay cash at its own cost instead of repairing or replacing at retail. In California, Choice-branded contracts are issued by Home Service Club of California.

Why it makes this list

  • The basic-versus-total split is specific enough to shop against.
  • Optional roof, septic, and well coverage is named.
  • The cash-settlement rule is disclosed on the public explainer, not only in a PDF.

Where it is thinner

  • No public monthly price or per-item cap on the page we used.
  • A basic plan can omit the air conditioner and the refrigerator.
  • A cash payout at the company’s cost can be less than a store receipt.

Choice Home Warranty

Questions people actually ask

Is a home warranty the same as homeowners insurance?

No. Insurance is for sudden, accidental loss: fire, theft, some storms, and liability. A home warranty is a service contract for mechanical breakdown from ordinary use. A lender may require insurance. A lender does not require this contract.

Are these the only companies worth calling?

No. The set is five brands with public plan pages detailed enough to compare without inventing prices. Local and regional contracts can be better in a specific state. Ask for that state’s sample agreement either way.

Will a plan cover a system that is already failing?

Usually not, if the failure is known. American Home Shield and Liberty say they do not require maintenance records and may cover unknown pre-existing breakdowns. Liberty’s HVAC Guard is the plan that explicitly says known pre-existing HVAC problems are covered. Cinch draws the same known-versus-unknown line. If the unit is already dead, assume it is excluded until the contract says otherwise.

Why do quotes refuse to match the prices on this page?

2-10 is the only company here that printed monthly prices on the page we reviewed, and even those can change with discounts, home size, and state. Everyone else prices from the address. Use the caps and the exclusions to compare, then use the quote for the premium and the service fee.

Does Hearthline sell these contracts?

No. Hearthline does not take applications, hold a service-contract license, or attach affiliate codes. The buttons and links leave this site for the company that would actually issue the contract.

How this page was built

On November 20, 2026 we read the public plan pages linked below and kept a number only when that page stated it. We did not mystery-shop claims, scrape reviews into a score, or take payment from these companies.

Home-warranty contracts are regulated as service contracts in many states, and the form you sign can differ from the national marketing page. If a sentence here and the sample contract disagree, the contract is the one that pays.